Politician · country

Josep Borrell on Gaza

Fierce critic of Gaza conduct (strong)

TL;DR

Josep Borrell strongly condemns Israel's actions in Gaza, alleging genocide and European complicity via arms sales.

Key Points

  • He proposed that EU Member States ban imports from illegal settlements and suspend the political dialogue with Israel following a year of unheeded pleas.

  • He stated in a speech that 'half of the bombs that fall on Gaza are made in Europe,' indicating European contribution to the conflict.

  • He called for collective global action and stressed Europe's need to increase its strategic responsibility regarding the Israel-Gaza war as of May 2024.

Summary

Josep Borrell, the former EU High Representative, has adopted a strongly critical stance on the war in Gaza, accusing Israel of committing genocide and what he describes as the largest ethnic-cleansing operation since World War II in pursuit of creating a 'splendid holiday destination' after clearing the territory of Palestinians. He explicitly links the horrors inflicted on Gaza to statements made by Israeli ministers, asserting that clear declarations of genocidal intent have been made and acted upon, noting the massive scale of explosive power used. He further argued that the international rules-based order is hanging by a thread due to the widespread disregard for international humanitarian law by belligerents, including Israel.

He has harshly criticized the European Union's perceived inaction, noting that expressions of regret are insufficient, especially given the bloc’s material contribution to the conflict. The former diplomat asserts that the EU supplies half the bombs falling on Gaza, implying that a lack of influence stems from a failure to leverage its Association Agreement or weapon supply chain. Therefore, he proposed concrete measures to EU Member States, such as banning imports from illegal settlements and suspending the political dialogue with Israel, arguing that the past approach has demonstrably failed. He called for collective global action and an increased strategic responsibility from Europe to influence conduct in the region.

Key Quotes

After a year of unheeded pleas by the Israeli authorities regarding respect for international law in the Gaza war, we cannot continue with business as usual.

“half of the bombs that fall on Gaza are made in Europe”

Frequently Asked Questions

Josep Borrell's position is one of strong condemnation of the conduct of the war in Gaza by Israel. He has accused Israel of committing genocide and carrying out ethnic cleansing. He believes that Europe has a responsibility to act, given its material ties to the conflict.

The former High Representative stated that half of the bombs dropped on Gaza were manufactured in Europe, implying a direct material link to the military actions. He argued that this connection means Europe could significantly influence Israel's conduct if it chose to use its leverage.

Josep Borrell proposed that EU Member States should ban imports originating from illegal Israeli settlements. He also requested an assessment that would lead to suspending the political dialogue between the EU and Israel, citing the failure of the previous approach.