George Soros on AIPAC
TL;DR
George Soros strongly criticized AIPAC for its pervasive political influence and for suppressing necessary criticism of Israeli policy.
Key Points
He asserted in April 2007 that AIPAC's influence endangered Israel by suppressing critical self-examination of US-Israeli policy.
He noted his concern that AIPAC's success in stifling divergent views lent credence to false antisemitic conspiracy myths.
In 2022, his Democracy PAC donated $1 million to J Street's Super PAC, a group AIPAC accused of undermining pro-Israel Democrats.
Summary
George Soros has positioned himself as a critic of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), arguing that its pervasive influence on both the Democratic and Republican parties has caused the United States to adopt a disastrously flawed policy regarding the Israeli-Palestinian relationship. In a 2007 essay, he accused the Washington-based organization of being "remarkably successful" in suppressing debate by aggressively attacking critics of Israeli policy as fomenters of antisemitism. He contended that this suppression endangered Israel by preventing a much-needed self-examination of policy, especially concerning negotiations that could lead to a viable peace settlement.
He suggested that AIPAC had exceeded its core mission by actively lobbying on issues beyond US-Israel relations, citing its support for the Iraq invasion and its efforts to influence UN appointments. Furthermore, he asserted that AIPAC's strong influence allows it to dictate terms to politicians, making it difficult for leaders to resist its positions, especially when doing so risks political backlash or accusations of being anti-Israel. Soros stated that dismantling this "wall of silence" surrounding the lobby was necessary for positive change in Middle East policy to occur.
Frequently Asked Questions
George Soros is a prominent critic of AIPAC, arguing that the organization wields too much influence over US politics regarding Israel. He has accused AIPAC of suppressing legitimate criticism of Israeli policies, which he believes is detrimental to Israel's long-term security.
The core of George Soros's critique regarding AIPAC's powerful influence and suppression of debate remains consistent from his 2007 statements. His subsequent financial support for J Street, which contrasts with AIPAC, suggests a continued divergence from that organization's political strategy.
George Soros explicitly stated that AIPAC's pervasive influence affects both major US political parties and prevents necessary dialogue on the Palestinian problem. He feels this influence has allowed the Bush administration to pursue a mistaken policy that jeopardizes peace efforts.
Sources8
On Israel, America and AIPAC
On Israel, America and AIPAC
George Soros on AIPAC and Israel – Partners For Progressive Israel
Soros attacks US pro-Israel lobby
AIPAC accused George Soros of undermining American politics. Is that antisemitic? – The Forward
Corrected: Soros adds voice to debate over Israel lobby
Soros & AIPAC Enter the Senate… - Between the Headlines Columbus
Billionaire George Soros donates $1m to J Street super PAC
* This is not an exhaustive list of sources.