Danielle Smith on Immigration
TL;DR
Danielle Smith's government is pursuing greater provincial control over immigration levels, often clashing with federal policy goals.
Key Points
The Premier expressed a desire for a referendum on federal immigration policy prior to her election.
She has argued that Alberta should have the authority to set its own immigration selection criteria separate from the federal government.
Her government has been criticized by some for how it has characterized the role of immigrants regarding economic issues.
Summary
Danielle Smith, as the Premier of Alberta, has made securing increased provincial control over immigration a central policy focus for her United Conservative Party government. Her stated goal is to ensure that immigration levels align more closely with the province's specific economic needs, particularly labour shortages in various sectors. This position has involved explicit calls for the federal government to devolve more authority to Alberta regarding the selection and intake of newcomers, aiming to tailor population growth to regional demands and infrastructure capacity.
However, this stance marks a notable evolution, as prior to achieving the premiership, Smith had expressed frustration over high immigration numbers and even suggested pursuing a provincial referendum on the issue. Furthermore, the administration has faced criticism from experts regarding the perceived flaws in its proposed provincial immigration policy adjustments and has been accused by political opponents of blaming immigrants for provincial issues. Despite these criticisms and the shift from an earlier skeptical tone, her current platform strongly emphasizes using provincial powers to manage and direct immigration flows.
Frequently Asked Questions
Danielle Smith's current position strongly advocates for increased provincial control over immigration levels and selection to better match Alberta's economic needs. She seeks to reduce federal oversight to allow for a more tailored approach to population growth within the province.
Yes, her stance appears to have evolved; earlier, she mentioned the possibility of a provincial referendum on the topic, indicating a skeptical view of current federal settings. Now, as Premier, the focus is more directly on gaining administrative control rather than holding a province-wide vote.
She has repeatedly stated that Alberta's immigration intake must be aligned with the province's specific labour market requirements. The Premier argues that the current federal system does not adequately account for the unique needs of Alberta's economy.
Sources5
Alberta could hold a referendum on federal immigration powers, Smith suggests
Danielle Smith's radio show: The hits and misses
Danielle Smith’s nine questions
Danielle Smith is now blaming immigrants for her own decision...
Experts say Alberta’s proposed immigrant policy changes are flawed
* This is not an exhaustive list of sources.