Portrait of Ted Cruz
Politician · organisation
Wikipedia (opens in new tab)

Ted Cruz on Judges

Demands judicial accountability (strong)

TL;DR

Ted Cruz strongly advocates for holding federal judges accountable, specifically calling for the impeachment of those he deems to have engaged in judicial overreach.

Key Points

  • He chaired a Senate Judiciary Subcommittee hearing titled “Impeachment: Holding Rogue Judges Accountable” to address judicial overreach in January 2026.

  • The senator publicly called for the impeachment of Chief Judge James Boasberg for authorizing secret non-disclosure orders related to subpoenas for Republican senators' phone records.

  • He also called for the impeachment of Judge Deborah Boardman over her eight-year sentence for the man who attempted to assassinate Justice Brett Kavanaugh, a sentence he deemed too lenient.

Summary

The senator has taken a strong public stance advocating for mechanisms of judicial accountability, centering his recent efforts on demanding the impeachment of specific federal judges for what he characterizes as judicial overreach, abuse of power, and subversion of the constitutional order. He argued during a Senate hearing that impeachable offenses need not be criminal, citing historical precedents where judges were removed for abuses of power on the bench, such as Judge James Boasberg for authorizing secret subpoenas against members of Congress and Judge Deborah Boardman for imposing an allegedly lenient sentence on the attempted assassin of a Supreme Court justice. He believes that life tenure without accountability for such misconduct leads to tyranny and that Congress must utilize impeachment to correct deep offenses that strike at the republic's architecture.

This focus on accountability through impeachment contrasts with the view that disagreement with judicial rulings should only be addressed through the appellate process. He views the actions of the targeted judges—including one who allegedly violated a statute protecting congressional records and another who significantly deviated from sentencing guidelines in a high-profile case—as breaches of public trust that the standard appeals process cannot remedy. By championing these impeachment efforts, he places himself in opposition to those who view such actions as threats to judicial independence and attempts to intimidate the judiciary for issuing adverse rulings against the administration he supports.

Key Quotes

“Rarer still, until now, were the deeper offenses the framers feared most — judges who, without necessarily breaking a criminal statute, violate the public trust, subvert the constitutional order or wield their office in ways that injure society itself,”

Frequently Asked Questions

Ted Cruz strongly believes that federal judges must be held accountable for misconduct that violates their public trust, even if it does not involve criminal charges. He argues that life tenure without accountability can devolve into tyranny. His primary mechanism for ensuring this accountability is through the process of impeachment.

Yes, the senator has explicitly called for the impeachment of at least two federal judges, James Boasberg and Deborah Boardman. He based these calls on specific rulings, including the approval of secret subpoena non-disclosure orders and a controversial sentencing decision, respectively. He asserts these actions meet the constitutional standard for removal.

He argues that impeachment is appropriate for abuses of power that subvert the constitutional order, which can stem from judicial conduct on the bench. While acknowledging that the standard for impeachment is broad, he contends that the specific actions of the judges he targeted went beyond ordinary disagreements correctable by appeal.