Josep Borrell on Iran
TL;DR
Josep Borrell strongly prioritizes the diplomatic preservation of the nuclear deal while condemning severe human rights abuses by Iranian authorities.
Key Points
He strongly advocated for salvaging the JCPOA, announcing a "final text" in August 2022 aimed at resurrecting the agreement.
He spoke with Foreign Minister Javad Zarif in January 2020, urging restraint to de-escalate tensions following the killing of General Qassem Soleimani.
The EU, under his tenure, adopted 10 sanctions packages in response to the 2022 protests alone against those responsible for human rights violations.
Summary
Josep Borrell, in his capacity as the EU High Representative, has centered much of his engagement with Iran on the preservation of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), advocating for diplomacy to avert nuclear proliferation and regional escalation. He has repeatedly stressed the JCPOA's role as a cornerstone of the non-proliferation architecture and has engaged in shuttle diplomacy, including a visit to Tehran in 2020, to overcome obstacles to its revival, even after expressing deep concern over regional tensions and developments like the killing of General Qassem Soleimani. His position has involved pushing for a final text to restore the agreement when talks stalled, while simultaneously warning of severe consequences should the deal collapse.
Concurrently, Borrell maintains a firm stance against the regime’s internal conduct, particularly its human rights record, explicitly condemning the ongoing repression against women and girls, which he has addressed publicly, including in speeches delivered in Strasbourg. In response to escalating human rights violations, especially following the 2022 protests, the EU, under his purview, has implemented multiple sanctions packages targeting those responsible. Despite this, there has been internal EU discord regarding other measures, such as designating the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) as a terrorist entity, a move he previously opposed on what he stated were legal grounds, illustrating a tension between his commitment to nuclear diplomacy and his response to the regime’s non-nuclear actions.
Key Quotes
He urged Iran to exercise restraint and carefully consider any reaction to avoid further escalation, which harms the entire region and its people.
“what can be negotiated has been negotiated,” and that it is time for political decisions to be made in the capitals.
Frequently Asked Questions
Josep Borrell's main focus has been the diplomatic effort to preserve the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), viewing it as crucial for non-proliferation. However, this focus runs parallel to his condemnation of the Iranian regime's severe human rights violations.
While his fundamental belief in diplomacy remains, the context has forced an evolution; he moved from pushing a near-final text in 2022 to acknowledging the failure of those efforts after Iran's breaches and internal crackdown. He has maintained a strong posture on imposing sanctions for human rights issues, even when differing on specific measures like the IRGC designation.
Josep Borrell has clearly stated the EU's strong position against human rights violations in Iran, particularly targeting the repression of women and girls. He has committed to continuing to use sanctions and bilateral contacts to demand an end to systemic discrimination.
Sources9
I'm sorry. I'm not able to access the website(s) you've provided.
Europe's IRGC Designation: Symbolism over Strategy - FPIF
Borrell's Failing Diplomacy: EU's Troubled Relationship With Iran
Iran: Speech by High Representative/Vice-President Josep Borrell on the ongoing repression against women | EEAS
Iran Responds to EU Final Text | Arms Control Association
Borrell in Tehran: How to overcome three obstacles to the Iran nuclear deal – European Council on Foreign Relations
I'm sorry. I'm not able to access the website(s) you've provided.
Iran: High Representative Josep Borrell spoke with Foreign Minister Javad Zarif | EEAS
I'm sorry. I'm not able to access the website(s) you've provided.
* This is not an exhaustive list of sources.