Politician · person

Jimmy Carter on Benjamin Netanyahu

Vocal critic of policies (strong)

TL;DR

Former President Jimmy Carter asserts that peace is impossible with Netanyahu because he does not sincerely desire a two-state solution.

Key Points

  • He stated in 2019 that there is “zero chance” for a two-state solution while Netanyahu remains prime minister, as he does not believe Netanyahu desires peace.

  • The former President has accused the Netanyahu government of deciding early on to adopt a one-state solution without granting Palestinians equal rights.

  • Israeli leaders, including the Prime Minister and President, have declined to meet with Jimmy Carter during his visits due to his expressed anti-Israel stance.

Summary

Jimmy Carter has expressed a strong, negative assessment of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, directly linking his leadership to the impossibility of achieving a two-state solution for the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The former President stated clearly that he does not believe Netanyahu wants peace and, in his view, the Israeli government under Netanyahu adopted a one-state solution approach early on, specifically by continuing control over the West Bank. This stance, Carter argued, inherently denies equal rights to Palestinians living under occupation, a situation he has previously likened to apartheid in his writings. He also implied a lack of a trusted mediator in the current dynamic.

Carter, who famously brokered the Camp David Accords between Egypt and Menachem Begin, contrasted the leadership styles, noting that while he admired Begin's courage in making concessions, he found Netanyahu constrained by his own deep beliefs and political alliances that make necessary compromises difficult. The former President suggested that Netanyahu's actions in continuing to expand settlements were contrary to expectations set during prior peace efforts. Furthermore, Israeli leaders have, in response to Carter's long-standing critical stance on Israeli policy, declined to meet with him during his visits.

Key Quotes

I don't see any way to make peace with Netanyahu as prime minister, I don't think he wants peace.

The Netanyahu government decided early on to adopt a one-state solution — but without giving them [the Palestinians] equal rights,”

These are the worst prospects for peace between Israel and the Palestinians for years,”

Frequently Asked Questions

Jimmy Carter has stated he does not see a way to make peace while Benjamin Netanyahu is prime minister, asserting that Netanyahu does not sincerely want a two-state solution. This assessment is rooted in Carter's view of Netanyahu's policies regarding the West Bank and Palestinian rights. He made these remarks in interviews around 2019 and 2020.

The provided information suggests Jimmy Carter's position has been consistently critical of Netanyahu's approach to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, particularly regarding the two-state solution. He has maintained a critical view of Israeli policy dating back to his 2006 book. His assessment of Netanyahu's intent appears to be a continuation of this long-standing critique.

Jimmy Carter asserted that the Netanyahu government decided early on to adopt a one-state solution, which involves Israel continuing its control over the West Bank. According to the former President, this path inevitably leads to the deprivation of equal rights for Palestinians. He made this claim in an interview published around 2015.